Only 73 percent of one kind of tuberculosis (TB) cases registered for treatment were successfully treated, much lower than the government-reported 84 percent success rate, according to a new study published in the US and UK-based health journal PLoS Medicine.
Untreated or partially treated TB patients may infect others, at least partially nullifying India’s attempts to beat back a disease that claims nearly half a million lives every year. Partially-treated TB could also result in drug-resistant TB, a more potent form of the disease that is expensive to treat.
India has more than a quarter of the world’s tuberculosis burden, with an estimated 2.8 million new cases in 2015. Improving TB diagnosis and care within the government system could reduce the spread of TB and TB deaths -- 480,000 in 2015.
The estimates in the study -- authored by a group of researchers, and published on October 25 -- are based on World Health Organisation data, data from India’s national TB programme and reviews of studies published by other researchers. The study analysed TB cases only within the government programme in India because of a lack of information about patients in the private sector -- estimated to be between 1.19 and 5.24 million in 2014.
Analysing where patients “are getting lost” within the government system could help improve the country-wide programme for TB control, said Ramnath Subbaraman, the lead author of the study, an infectious disease physician and lecturer at Harvard Medical School.
The study estimated lower rates of treatment success than those reported by the national TB programme in its annual report: 73 percent of all new smear-positive cases -- cases that were positive for the TB bacteria when tested microbiologically -- registered for treatment were successfully treated, compared to 84 percent, as reported by the government in the 2015 annual report for TB.
For patients who either failed or defaulted in previous treatment, the rate of success when retreated was 51.6 percent, according to the study. The government reported that 63 percent of such patients registered for treatment were cured in 2013.
Similarly, the study estimated that 82 percent smear-negative patients -- those that do not test positive when tested microbiologically but are still infected with TB --registered for treatment were successfully cured of TB. The national programme claimed that the rate of successful treatment was 90 percent of such TB cases registered for treatment.
What the national TB programme does not record: How many were cured?
Part of the gap between the numbers reported by the study and the national TB control programme can be explained by different definitions of success in TB treatment.
The study estimated treatment success by patients who did not relapse after one year of completing treatment.
Even though the Standards for TB Care in India recommend that patients should be examined after six and 12 months of treatment completion, the national tuberculosis programme does not provide information in its annual report on the status of all patients after one year. For instance, for several categories of patients -- such as those that had extra-pulmonary TB or TB that tested negative when tested microbiologically -- the national TB control programme reported how many patients completed treatment, but not how many were cured.
Only tracking “treatment completion is not a good enough measure of how well the programme is doing”, according to Subbaraman. He said that all patients in the nationwide programme should be tracked for one year after they complete treatment to make sure they don’t relapse.
Officials from the Revised National Tuberculosis Control Programme did not reply, despite repeated requests for comment.
Overall, the public health sector successfully treated less than half of all TB cases in the country, the study estimated. Out of 2.7 million estimated cases of TB in India in 2013, only 39 percent completed treatment in the national TB control programme, without relapsing after a year of completing treatment.
The study also highlighted two other gaps in the programme-diagnosis and registration for treatment.
Out of those TB patients who reached the government system -- 72 percent of India’s total TB cases in 2013 -- more than half a million are either not diagnosed correctly, or diagnosed but not registered for treatment, the study found.
Patients are not diagnosed with TB because not everyone with TB can be diagnosed by microbiological testing of sputum -- the most common way of diagnosing patients within the national TB control programme. Patients who are diagnosed go “missing” from the government system because they aren’t immediately told they have TB, or because they don’t want to come back to the government for treatment.
“Since this population of half a million patients is willing to engage with public sector services in some capacity, they present a significant opportunity for strengthening TB control,” the study said. The study recommended strengthening diagnostic facilities, patient tracking, and making TB care more patient-friendly to improve diagnosis and patient retention within the government system.
(In an arrangement with IndiaSpend.org, a data-driven, non-profit, public interest journalism platform, with whom Shreya Shah is a reporter/editor. The views expressed are strictly those of IndiaSpend.)