SC’s no to intervene in whistleblower law irks ªdvocate Prashant Bhushan
The Supreme Court on Thursday refused to intervene in the legislative process on the amendments to the law on whistleblower’s protection by brushing aside the protest of activist-lawyer Prashant Bhushan that these would dilute the provisions of the original 2011 Act.
The apex court said Parliament is “seized of” the matter and by asking the legislature about the proposed amendments, it cannot “breach” the limit.
As the bench headed by Chief Justice J S Khehar made its mind clear that it would not keep the PIL, filed way back in 2004, pending, Bhushan, appearing for NGO ‘Parivartan’, expressed his dissatisfaction by raising his pitch.
“We can’t breach our limit. How can we say Parliament should do this or that?,” the bench, also comprising Justice D Y Chandrachud, said.
During the hearing when the bench said that it would dispose of the petition, a visibly agitated Bhushan said, “I have been soft.”
“You want to be hard,” the bench said which led Bhushan to reply, “Yes. I want to say something emphatically.”
Bhushan said that issuing direction to Parliament and the government was not same thing and submitted that he can cite a number of judgements in this regard.
The lawyer said he was not asking for a direction to Parliament, but since the President’s assent to the Act, which is yet to be notified, is awaited, certain features of the important law can be considered and a direction can be given.
As the bench was not inclined to accept his submissions, Bhushan said that he has not been allowed to place before it the problems relating to the Whistleblower Protection Act, 2011.