Millennium Post

Judicial scrutiny of Aadhaar is limited, Apex court told

Judicial scrutiny of Aadhaar is limited, Apex court told
New Delhi: The Central government on Wednesday told the Supreme Court that Aadhaar unique identification number is a policy decision in the larger interest of the state, and was put in place after expert inputs, thus the scope of judicial scrutiny into it was limited.
Citing the enormous benefits of the scheme, Attorney General K.K.Venugopal told five judge constitution bench of Chief Justice Dipak Misra, Justice A.K. Sikri, Justice A.M. Khanwilkar, Justice D.Y. Chandrachud and Justice Ashok Bhushan that it has helped in curbing the leakages in the disbursal of benefits under welfare schemes.
Telling the bench that the legitimate interest of the state or the larger public interest runs through the entire Aadhaar Act, he said that it has helped in dissipation of subsides covered under Section 7, preventing black money and money laundering by linking unique identification number with bank accounts.
The court was told that linking of Aadhaar with PAN has helped in checking evasion of tax and making its mandatory linking with SIM card has aided in preventing terrorism and protecting national security. To buttress his arguments that similar steps were taken in other countries and were upheld by their courts, the Attorney General took the constitution bench through the judgments of the American Supreme Court which have upheld the fingerprint imaging for social security cards.
He cited 19 judgments of US top court as well as United Nations report "Leaving no one behind: Imperative of inclusive development" to drive home his point that collection of biometric data of the Aadhaar holders was not invasion of privacy or or means to surveliance.
At this Justice Sikri observed that the position taken by the European courts including by the German court was diametrically different to the position taken by US courts.
Team MP

Team MP

Our contributor helps bringing the latest updates to you


Share it
Top