Karnan refuses medical test, says he is 'absolutely normal'
Justice Karnan also gave the team of doctors a written note where he said he had declined medical treatment.
Justice CS Karnan on Thursday declined to undergo medical examination ordered by the Supreme Court. A four-member medical team from a government hospital in Kolkata reached Justice Karnan's home in New Town in Kolkata on Thursday morning but he declined examination, stating that he is "quite normal and has a stable mind".
Justice Karnan also gave the team of doctors a written note where he said he had declined medical treatment. The note said, "I declined to avail medical treatment since I am quite normal and have a stable mind."
He also said the provision of a medical team for his check-up is equivalent to "insult and harassment". Further, he stated that since the consent of guardians was required to hold such a medical test, and given that none of his family members were present to act as guardians, he said the medical test could not be held.
"Further my strong view about the Supreme Court order (is that) it amounts to insult and harassment towards the judge (myself). As my family members are not here, there is no such consent. So any medical test cannot be held", he said. He told the examiners that his wife and son were in Chennai while another son is working in France.
Calcutta High Court Justice C.S. Karnan on Thursday declined to undergo any check-up after a medical team turned up at his residence following a Supreme Court order, saying he is "absolutely normal". He termed the seven apex court judges as "terrorists" and the order an insult to a "Dalit judge".
"Medical treatment is not required to (sic) me. Medical treatment is required to (sic) the patient. I am alright. I am not a patient. Yes, I am more than normal," he said.
Karnan told the team of four doctors from the state-run Calcutta Pavlov Hospital that that his wife and sons were not in Kolkata and such a test can't be done without the consent of his family.
"My wife and one son is in Chennai. The other son is abroad. So in the absence of any guardian, my family, I cannot allow you to examine me, as that is legally wrong," Karnan told the doctors after inviting them inside his New Town residence in Kolkata's north eastern fringes and offering them tea.
Karnan handed a signed letter to the doctors addressed to the chairman of the medical board constituted to examine him.
"Today you and your team came along with top police officers attached to the Kolkata Police department in order to provide medical treatment to me as per the direction/order/instruction of the Honourable Supreme Court. However, I declined to avail the medical treatment since I am absolutely normal with a stable mind," the letter said.
He alleged the Supreme Court order was an "insult" to a "Dalit judge".
"Furthermore, it's my strong view that the Supreme Court order amounts to an insult and harassment to a Dalit judge (myself)," Karnan said in the letter.
On Thursday, Karnan's housing complex 'Rosedale' swarmed with a large number of media persons, police team and onlookers, ahead of the visit of the medical team.
A seven-judge Supreme Court bench headed by Chief Justice Jagdish Singh Khehar on Monday directed the setting up of a medical board to examine Karnan on May 4 and submit the evaluation report on May 8.
Karnan has been engaged in an over three-month long confrontation with the apex court. He is facing contempt charges for degrading the judiciary and making allegations of corruption against several Supreme Court judges.
On Thursday, Karnan seemed to relish his multiple interactions with the media. He spoke to the journalists both before the arrival of the medical team and also after they had left with his signed letter.
He launched an all-out attack on the apex court judges, calling them "mad" and "terrorists" and accusing them of "colluding with corrupt judges" and "sharing the corruption amount".
Karnan also termed the apex court order as a "mad order passed by mad judges" and alleged that he was being targeted.
"I am wondering how the seven judges (are) supporting corrupted judges. Why the seven judges are colluding with corrupted judges. Seven judges colluding with corrupt judges means they share the corruption amount.
"My assumption and presumption is the seven judges shared the corruption amount held by 20 judges."
"Therefore they are taking personal interest. How all of a sudden they prevented my judicial work, administrative work? Where is the provision? How did they issue a bailable warrant against me? Am I a terrorist, an anti-social element?"
"But the seven judges are terrorists, please note down," he told media persons, who were taken aback by his virulent attack.
Karnan then offered his "logic".
"The Pakistani terrorists are continuously attempting to disturb the Indian peace. Likewise, the seven judges are continuously operating their judicial power out of law and spoiling the judiciary. Therefore they are terrorists in the judiciary."
Karnan claimed the seven judges were "not suitable" for the nation.
"My deep request on behalf of 125 crores of Indian people.... after the issuing of suo-moto contempt proceedings, now the public have lost confidence and trust in the judiciary. Therefore, once again I request the seven judges to do the right thing by resigning their judicial posts," he said.
Karnan even asked the media to compare the "quality" of the orders passed by him and the Supreme Court bench.
"Compare my orders with the seven judges' orders. which are quality orders? Which are suitable for execution?" he asked.
He also had an advice for a journalist.
"Without omitting any point, incorporate in your newspaper, senior madam."
Earlier on Monday, the Supreme Court had ordered a medical examination for Justice Karnan. The court had said that the examination should be done by May 5 and the report submitted by May 18. The bench, which was presided over and headed by the Chief Justice of India, Justice JS Khehar, also sent directives that no lower courts or tribunal courts should take orders from Justice Karnan.