High court asks Payal Abdullah to ‘gracefully’ vacate govt bungalow
Payal, who has been residing at 7, Akbar Road bungalow since 1999, however, refused to move out and urged the court to pass an order.
The court then said a detailed order would be passed with regard to the time within which she and her children would have to vacate the bungalow. “Will you gracefully evict or I should pass an order?” said Justice Indermeet Kaur asked Payal’s counsel, who categorically stated that the court should pass the order.
The judge also orally observed that every person who retires from the office has to move out. The judge also noted that the Delhi Police will provide security to Payal and her children, who are ‘Z’ and ‘Z plus’ security protectees, during their stay in the national Capital.
On August 16, a trial court too, had asked Payal to move out of the house in Lutyen’s Zone here.
The High Court was hearing Payal’s plea, seeking that she and her children be not evicted from 7, Akbar Road (type VIII) bungalow here or an alternative accommodation be provided in view of their security status and threat to their lives.
The Centre, however, opposed her contention to retain the accommodation on the ground of security threat and said it is for Delhi Police to ensure her safety for her stay here. The Centre, through its counsel Anurag Ahluwalia, appearing for the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA), submitted that there is no substantial reduction in the security given to Payal since she started living in the bungalow.
“The Delhi Police will take care of the security personnel who will be deployed at the residence where she will move,” the MHA counsel said.
The Centre told the court that government accommodation, on security grounds, is given only to SPG protectees. It said that a “general threat to them is perceived from Kashmiri militants for being the family member of Omar Abdullah and Farooq Abdullah, and in Delhi their threat quotient is assessed to be not as high as in Kashmir”.
The Centre also said there is “no input with it indicating any specific or imminent threat to Payal Abdullah”. The High Court had on July 12 given protection to them against eviction.
The J&K government opposed Payal’s stay in the bungalow, saying it was faced with an extremely piquant situation as it does not have an appropriate accommodation to house the Chief Minister in Delhi befitting her position and security imperatives.
Meanwhile, Payal has filed an application, seeking perjury proceedings against a Central government official for filing a false affidavit before the court that she and her children are not central government protectees.
In their plea, Payal and her children have claimed that the Centre, through a letter dated September 9, 2015, allotted the bungalow to J&K as the Chief Minister’s residence with retrospective effect from August 11, 2009, without following the due process of law which was thus illegal.
They contended that the website of the Department of Hospitality and Protocol of the Government of Jammu and Kashmir shows that the residence of Chief Minister of the state was 5, Prithviraj Road.
Their petition filed through advocate Amit Khemka, claimed that they moved High Court as Omar Abdullah in his response to the estate officer’s show-cause notice had said that he was no longer in occupation of the premises, and hence, the authority was free to take over the premises.
The petitioners, including the couple’s two children, have sought parity with Priyanka Gandhi, Subramanian Swamy and several others who have been granted government accommodation on security grounds. The petitioners have contended that the eviction order was passed without allowing them to lead evidence and without granting any personal hearing to them. As per the eviction order, the petitioners were given 15 days to vacate the premises.
- 17 May 2020 6:47 PM GMT
- 6 May 2020 6:06 PM GMT
- 8 May 2020 8:02 PM GMT
- 22 Aug 2019 6:17 PM GMT
- 25 Oct 2017 3:32 PM GMT
- 4 Jun 2020 7:57 PM GMT
- 4 Jun 2020 7:56 PM GMT
- 4 Jun 2020 7:54 PM GMT
- 4 Jun 2020 7:52 PM GMT
- 4 Jun 2020 7:51 PM GMT