Hedging its bets on coal to bring power to the people
More than a fifth of India’s population lacks access to electricity. This is a major development challenge. Prime Minister Narendra Modi has promised to bring affordable access to electricity to all of these people by 2019.
While Modi has committed to increasing renewable generation, India is also increasing coal production. India is the world’s third-largest coal producer and its second-largest coal importer. This is creating a growing tension between development and India’s efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions to combat climate change.
The world economy is changing faster than ever and Asia is at the forefront of its transformation. The growth, led by China over the past decade and more recently by India, shows that Asia has significant progress to make.
But there are enormous challenges in realising the dream of the Asian Century. For instance, in India, 22 percent of the population is living below the national poverty level. Only 47 percent of the households have access to a toilet, while 105 million people lack access to clean drinking water and 240 million people don’t have access to electricity.
But there is also bright news for India. The country’s economy is growing quickly and will soon surpass China’s. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), in its recent interim economic outlook, has predicted that India’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) will grow by 7.4 percent in 2016 and 7.3 percent in 2017.
In his electoral victory speech, Modi promised a “shining India” of new hopes and aspirations. The reality, however, is far more complex. Resources are the focal point of this tension, particularly the increasing demand for energy. India’s energy demands will increase significantly, driven by rapid urbanisation, improved electricity access, and an expanding manufacturing base.
Energy security is closely linked to food and water security, which are the backbones of the nation and a growing challenge in the face of climate change.The Indian government and businesses are addressing these issues by managing supply, increasing production of coal-based thermal plants and growing renewable energy sources. Coal supplies around half of India’s total energy.
What role for coal?
Will constraints on resources, particularly access to affordable coal, disrupt India’s economic growth? India is the world’s third-largest producer of coal for electricity. While production has increased over the past few decades, the pace of growth has been insufficient to meet demand. Consequently, India has become more reliant on imported coal.
India’s thermal coal imports have increased from almost zero in the 1990s to having it overtake Japan as the world’s second-largest importer in 2013. The Indian government seems to promise adequate supply to its coal-fired electricity generation capacity by expanding its coal production as well as encouraging imports.
For example, the Power and Coal Minister, Piyush Goyal, stated last year that the nation would step up domestic production and stop imports of coal for electricity (not coal for manufacturing) by 2017. However, growing economic growth and population may not allow this.
The Modi government’s plans to give access to affordable electricity to all Indians within the next five years cannot be achieved without importing coal. During the recent visit of India’s Energy Minister to Australia, the Minister admitted that the country will need more coal imports, possibly including from Australia.
Although in short term, the case for Australian coal in India may be weakening due to the current global economic slowdown, India will have to rely on imported coal at least in the immediate future to increase its economic growth. This is reflected in the case of Adani, which is trying to develop a huge Carmichael coal mine in Queensland to supply India with thermal coal. India’s domestic production of coal is constrained for a variety of reasons. India’s coal reserves are not only insufficient but also unevenly distributed among regions.
A further challenge related to the energy sector is a lack of private participation. Until 2014 coal mining was allowed only for government and private companies directly using coal for electricity and manufacturing.
The Modi government amended this rule to enable private companies to mine coal for sale in the open market. This may help create a more favourable coal market for both foreign and domestic investors and increase domestic production.
Although the Modi government is keen to increase production of domestic coal mines through privatisation, challenges still remain, such as pollution. The costs associated with pollution from coal-fired power stations are very large, as we can see from China.
China’s health minister from 2007-13, Chen Zhu, stated that lung cancer is now the leading cause of death in China as a result of pollution. This required China to spend an extra US$278 billion over five years to control pollution, mainly caused by coal-fired power plants.
India will have to tackle a very similar situation in the future. Hence, coal energy consumption is likely to be one of the defining issues of India’s economy in the 21st century, particularly the way in which the nation simultaneously addresses climate change and access to energy.
DOWN TO EARTH
(Tapan Sarkar is Senior Lecturer, Department of International Business & Asian Studies, Griffith Asia Institute, Griffith University. The views are personal. This article was originally published on The Conversation.)