From Proxies to Politicians in Bihar

Thirty-five years ago, Bhagirathi Devi was a sweeper in the block development office in Narkatiyaganj, a town in Bihar’s West Champaran district.

Today, she is a three-term member of the legislative assembly (MLA) of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Bhagirathi represents the Ramnagar (formerly Shikarpur) constituency in northwestern Bihar, one of 34 female MLAs in the 243-member Vidhan Sabha.

A Mahadalit–as the Bihar government started calling the poorest of low-caste Dalits in 2007– Bhagirathi Devi joined politics as a reaction to what she saw around her.

“I was angry at the injustice and cruelty meted out to the poor, especially poor women, who came to the block development officer’s office,” said Bhagirathi Devi, 65. “That was the day I decided to enter politics and teach the officers a lesson,” she said.

Since she quit her job as a sweeper in 1980, Bhagirathi Devi spent the next several years creating Mahila Sangathan (women’s groups) in Narkatiyaganj block, organising women and stirring awareness around issues that included domestic violence, violence against Dalits and fair wages.

Gradually, she expanded her political activism to other blocks in the district, going to jail in 1991 for organising demonstrations.

Bhagirathi Devi’s decision to enter politics was not easy for a poor Mahadalit family with six children (her husband is a railway employee). It was particularly challenging to organise her household before she set off every day, travelling to nearby villages. Her husband was doubtful. “Will you take care of the house or do politics,” he asked. She answered, “I will take care of the house and do politics as well”.

Such was the strength of her conviction that Bhagirathi Devi separated from her husband for the next five years, taking him back only when he realised that there was no turning back for her.

It had taken a decade of grassroots organising before she entered party politics, and ten more years before she got a BJP election ticket.

Today, she is seen in the legislative assembly, the Vidhan Sabha, as an MLA, who will not be silenced easily.

Bhagirathi Devi’s political journey, while being one of grit and determination, is also a reminder of the difficult choices women politicians, especially from marginalised groups, have to make and yet be consigned to the margins of political landscape, always spoken of as “proxies” of a male relative.

It is also a reminder of the restricted spaces for women in Bihar’s–and India’s–political parties, unless political lineage backs them.

Bhagirathi Devi represents, as IndiaSpend reported, a remarkable surge in female MLAs that otherwise backward Bihar has witnessed over the last decade. However, are these women MLAs truly empowered or are they proxies for powerful male relatives?

The term ‘proxy’ is largely used for women in panchayats (village councils), put forward by male relatives to contest seats they had to vacate following the 33% reservation for women under the 73rd amendment of the constitution, or when the men became ineligible after criminal convictions.

The term was further made infamous by Lalu Yadav, who installed his wife Rabri Devi as Bihar’s Chief Minister after his incarceration in a fodder scam.

If proxies were defined as women put forward to contest elections because their male relatives had to step down, mostly due to criminal convictions, Bihar data now dispels this widely held myth.

Of Bihar’s 34 female MLAs, only six have contested seats vacated by male relatives, usually husbands, according to data published on Myneta.in. It is a public-interest website run by Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR), an advocacy, which tracks political candidates nationwide. The majority, 82% of women MLAs, have won elections of their merit.

However, the term ‘proxy’ is used for women MLAs with undertones of gender and class bias. Media stories on female political candidates have often furthered this narrative.

<g data-gr-id="111">Leshi</g> Singh, an MLA from Dhamdaha in eastern Bihar and widow of <g data-gr-id="112">Butan</g> Singh (against whom many criminal cases had been filed), was called his proxy long after his death. However, the well-educated, male politicians who stepped in after the death of their fathers are seen as carrying forth their legacy.

For some women who enter politics sphere as ‘proxies’, it is an opportunity for political and personal advancement.

Bima Bharti, a JD(U) MLA from <g data-gr-id="109">Rupauli</g> in Purnia district in eastern Bihar, is a good example. She entered politics as an independent MLA in 2000, at the behest of her husband Avdhesh Singh Mandal, with pending criminal cases against him.

Barely literate, in 2010 she filed a criminal complaint against her husband for domestic violence. It led to his arrest, an uncommon occurrence in a state where politicians usually browbeat the police. Bharti went on to become a minister in the cabinet of Chief Minister Nitish Kumar.

Critics also assume that women with poor educational qualifications are almost always akin to puppets, with real power with male relatives.

Like Bhagirathi Devi, a fifth-class pass, Jyothi Devi, the MLA representing Barachatti constituency in Gaya district of Southern Bihar, disproved that assumption.

From Bihar’s most backward community, the Musahars–with literacy rates between 2% and 10%, according to this paper–Jyothi Devi has a long history of organising Musahar women and children. She has created <g data-gr-id="114">anganwadis</g> (child care centres) and self-help groups.

Despite her achievements, Devi is often spoken of as a relative of former Chief Minister Jitan Ram Manjhi, someone she must owe her political career.

If educational qualifications alone were an indicator of empowerment, then female MLAs in Bihar Vidhan Sabha are not doing badly. As many as 32% of them have graduate degrees and above while 41% have some form of formal school education.

Five female MLAs have doctoral degrees. Of these, Prof. Sukhada Pandey (BJP) and Usha Sinha (Janata Dal-United), were former college, principals.

Of the rest, 17% of female MLAs have declared themselves ‘literate’, a category that could range from being able to read and write to being home schooled or self-taught.

Of 34 MLAs, three have been ministers at various times over the past five years: <g data-gr-id="110">Leshi</g> Singh, Bima Bharti and Ranju Geeta. Neeta Chowdhry of the JD(U) is the chief deputy whip of her party.

“I insist on speaking I am neither afraid of Lalu Yadav nor Nitish Kumar. I am only accountable to the electorate that elects me” said Bhagirathi Devi, when asked about space for women to speak and intervene in the assembly.

Women MLAs in Bihar appear to have restricted speaking time in the House.

On International Women’s Day, Chief Minister Nitish Kumar had to intervene to ask the speaker to allow women members to be allowed to speak.

Lalu Yadav had famously told Bhagirathi Devi in the House that she was “like his aunt”, a polite way of asking her to shut up.

While some female MLAs are indeed fronts for male relatives, they are–as we noted–a minority. Dismissing the rest as proxies will not serve the cause of governance.