Supreme court junks pleas challenging AFSPA dilution
New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday rejected the appeal of over 300 Army personnel challenging the lodging of FIRs against soldiers involved in operations in Manipur and Jammu and Kashmir, where AFSPA is in force, though the Centre contended that it would have a "demoralising effect" on soldiers who are fighting terrorism.
The apex court brushed aside the fervent request of the Centre which supported the plea and said the issue should be "debated and discussed" so that a mechanism is evolved "where hands of our soldiers do not shake while fighting terrorism".
The Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act (AFSPA) gives special rights and immunity to security forces in carrying out various operations in "disturbed" areas.
The government said that armed forces were operating in an "altogether different situation" in disturbed areas and a balance has to be struck, but the apex court said that it was for the government, and not the courts, to come out with an internal mechanism so "that if somebody loses his life like this, it should be looked into".
"But who has stopped you from coming out with a mechanism? Why you require our intervention? These are issues which you have to discuss, not the courts," a bench of justices Madan B Lokur and U U Lalit told Solicitor General (SG) Tushar Mehta, who was representing the Centre.
"When there is a loss of life, even in an encounter, should not the human life demands that it should be looked into and investigation should be done," the bench observed.
As soon as the apex court said it was dismissing the plea, the SG stood up and said he should be heard as the Centre wants that the issue is debated.
"There has to be a mechanism where hands of our soldiers do not shake while fighting terrorism," Mehta said, adding, "human life has a value which can never be disputed".
"The fact that over 300 soldiers of our country have to pray for this is itself unfortunate," he said, adding, "It has a demoralising effect. The country cannot afford that our soldiers are demoralised. Please do not stop the debate".