SC asks govt to apprise on batch parity in Army promotion

The Supreme Court on Thursday asked the government to apprise it about the <g data-gr-id="18">factual</g> position on the issue of “batch parity” in promotion of army officers of the rank of Colonel and above belonging to various branches like the Armoured Corps, Engineering, Infantry and Artillery.

A bench comprising Justices T S Thakur and Kurian Joseph asked Additional Solicitor General Maninder Singh, appearing for the Ministry of Defence, to state the factual and legal positions on the issue concerning army promotions. The issue was raised when Meenakshi Lekhi, appearing for some Army officers, alleged that the 2009 promotion policy was aimed at providing an edge to officers of the Infantry and discriminated against officers belonging to other divisions.

The ASG referred to the existing policy and said that army officers of certain branches were given “combat edge” in promotions and it has never been disputed. Lekhi, however, said the position in the army was not like UPSC where promotions of IAS, IPS and other cadres are based on rankings. The successful candidates of NDA and CDS in the army are considered as a group and cannot be discriminated in promotions, she contended.

The bench will resume hearing the matter on September 22. Earlier, the court had asked the Centre to file a response as to whether it had approved the Army’s “command exit promotion” policy which was quashed by the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) meant for officers of the rank of Colonel and above from January 2009. It had also asked the Defence Secretary to file an affidavit stating “whether the government had accepted the recommendations of the AV Singh Committee (AVSC) with regard to the ‘command exit promotion policy’”.