Russia wants more for nuclear power if made liable for mishap
15 Oct 2012 7:12 AM IST
On the eve of a key bilateral meeting, Russia said that the cost of the next phase of the Kudankulam atomic project would escalate if was asked to bear additional liabilities arising from a possible nuclear accident.
'If there are several points that require additional assurances, of course, it will require additional money to be paid by India,' the visiting Russian deputy prime minister Dmitry Rogozin told reporters here ahead of the Inter-Governmental Commission meeting on Monday.
With differences in perception over India's civil nuclear liability law, the negotiations on the units III and IV of the Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant [KNPP] in Tamil Nadu have become a point of contention between Moscow and New Delhi.
While Russia argues that the civil nuclear liability law should not apply to these units, as the agreement on them predates the 2010 civil liability law, and could be seen as 'grandfathered' by the original 1988 agreement, India has clearly stated that making an exception for Russia will amount to diluting its civil nuclear law, which will encourage the US and France to seek similar exemptions, which it cannot afford.
The estimated cost of units III and IV is USD 6.4 billion, of which USD 3.4 billion will be taken care of by Russian state credits.
Citing the lessons learnt from the 1986 Chernobyl nuclear disaster, Rogozin, who will co-chair the Inter-Governmental Commission meeting on Trade, Economic, Scientific, Technological and Cultural Cooperation [IRIGC-TEC] with the external affairs minister S M Krishna, underlined that the atomic technology that Russia was providing to India was 'state-of-the-art' and people should not have fears over it.
'Having suffered the Chernobyl nuclear catastrophe, we are aware of the dangers. After that we created state-of-the-art and advanced technologies comparable with those available in the world. As for the nuclear project under construction in India, it will be the most reliable in the world. As head of the committee [Rusatom] on nuclear cooperation with India, so I am responsible for my words,' he said.
Being held ahead of the Russian president Vladimir Putin's visit, the two ministers will also set the agenda for the annual summit talks between Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Putin on 1 November.
BUT ASSURES IT WON’T GIVE ARMS TO INDIA’S ENEMIES
Russia firmly assured India on Sunday that it would not arm its 'enemies', with the visiting deputy prime minister Dmitry Rogozin also indicating Moscow's willingness to expand cooperation in defence production by building a new transport aircraft and battle tanks.
'You must understand that we do not deal with your enemies. We don't deliver any arms to them.... If you see otherwise, you may spit on my face,' Rogozin told reporters here when asked if Russia would supply arms to Pakistan.
He said Russia has no restrictions in delivering arms and weapons to India 'because there are no conflicts and contradictions in our relations'. 'We never created problems for India on its frontiers in difference from other countries. That is a political advantage [for Russia] as a friend of India,' the Russian leader said.
'If there are several points that require additional assurances, of course, it will require additional money to be paid by India,' the visiting Russian deputy prime minister Dmitry Rogozin told reporters here ahead of the Inter-Governmental Commission meeting on Monday.
With differences in perception over India's civil nuclear liability law, the negotiations on the units III and IV of the Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant [KNPP] in Tamil Nadu have become a point of contention between Moscow and New Delhi.
While Russia argues that the civil nuclear liability law should not apply to these units, as the agreement on them predates the 2010 civil liability law, and could be seen as 'grandfathered' by the original 1988 agreement, India has clearly stated that making an exception for Russia will amount to diluting its civil nuclear law, which will encourage the US and France to seek similar exemptions, which it cannot afford.
The estimated cost of units III and IV is USD 6.4 billion, of which USD 3.4 billion will be taken care of by Russian state credits.
Citing the lessons learnt from the 1986 Chernobyl nuclear disaster, Rogozin, who will co-chair the Inter-Governmental Commission meeting on Trade, Economic, Scientific, Technological and Cultural Cooperation [IRIGC-TEC] with the external affairs minister S M Krishna, underlined that the atomic technology that Russia was providing to India was 'state-of-the-art' and people should not have fears over it.
'Having suffered the Chernobyl nuclear catastrophe, we are aware of the dangers. After that we created state-of-the-art and advanced technologies comparable with those available in the world. As for the nuclear project under construction in India, it will be the most reliable in the world. As head of the committee [Rusatom] on nuclear cooperation with India, so I am responsible for my words,' he said.
Being held ahead of the Russian president Vladimir Putin's visit, the two ministers will also set the agenda for the annual summit talks between Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Putin on 1 November.
BUT ASSURES IT WON’T GIVE ARMS TO INDIA’S ENEMIES
Russia firmly assured India on Sunday that it would not arm its 'enemies', with the visiting deputy prime minister Dmitry Rogozin also indicating Moscow's willingness to expand cooperation in defence production by building a new transport aircraft and battle tanks.
'You must understand that we do not deal with your enemies. We don't deliver any arms to them.... If you see otherwise, you may spit on my face,' Rogozin told reporters here when asked if Russia would supply arms to Pakistan.
He said Russia has no restrictions in delivering arms and weapons to India 'because there are no conflicts and contradictions in our relations'. 'We never created problems for India on its frontiers in difference from other countries. That is a political advantage [for Russia] as a friend of India,' the Russian leader said.
Next Story
