Govt challenges HC order on scrapping mgmt quota

The AAP government on Monday approached the Delhi high court, challenging a single Bench order that restored the management quota for nursery admissions in private unaided schools in Delhi.

A division Bench of Chief Justice G Rohini and Justice Jayant Nath agreed to hear the appeal of Delhi’s Aam Aadmi Party government on Wednesday. A Bench of Justice Manmohan on February 4, in an interim order, put on hold the city government’s January 6 circular scrapping 62 criteria, including the management quota, but accepted 11 criteria proposed by the private schools’ association, saying some of the 62 criteria fixed for private schools for nursery admissions were “untenable”. The court restored the management quota, saying the private unaided private schools are “entitled to full autonomy” in administration.

The government filing the appeal before division Bench said the practice of management quota was “deleterious” for school education’s development in Delhi and hence “must be stopped” and also it was “wholly non-transparent and susceptible to misuse”. Upholding the autonomy of private unaided schools, the court said: “Promoters of a school who make investment at their own personal risk are entitled to full autonomy in administration, including the right to admit students”, and held that the government’s order infringed on their autonomy and students’ rights.

“The private unaided schools have maximum autonomy in day-to-day administration, including the right to admit students,” it said but asked the AAP government to take action against erring private schools which were “demanding money” from parents to admit kids under the management quota.

The January 6 order was passed “without any authority under law” or without approval of LG Najeeb Jung, and was in direct conflict with the 2007 order (after recommendations of the expert Ganguly Committee) issued by the LG, which accorded freedom to private unaided recognised schools to frame their own guidelines for nursery admissions, it added.