Logging in will submit your comments on articles instantly without administrator moderation.
* indicates mandatory.
Keep me logged in
NE youth murder case: Fourth accused arrested
One more accused was arrested by the police, on Tuesday, for the alleged killing of the 30-year-old youth from Manipur that led to an uproar in the national capital on Monday.
75-yr-old dairy owner found dead
RS members concerned over rising power tariff
Delhi Police urges senior citizens to register in scheme
Centre plans special session to showcase rich cultural heritage of NE
Man held with leopard skin
Dubai tops chart as international hotspot, Mumbai first as domestic destination
Kin of victim gets over Rs 27L as compensation
Court seeks govt view on using eco-friendly engine
Kejriwal meets families of Indians stranded in Iraq
Katju fires fresh salvo at Lahoti over corrupt TN judge charge
Asking six questions, former Supreme Court of India judge Markandey Katju on Tuesday fired a fresh salvo at Justice RC Lahoti after he created a furore alleging that three ex-Chief Justices of India had allowed a judge under corruption cloud to continue in office.
Proposed NCTC has been kept in abeyance, says Kiren Rijiju
Govt to amend Act to make hoarding non-bailable wrong
Nefarious practices rife in medical sector: Vardhan
3 businessmen found dead inside car in RK Puram
Bird hits scare IGI officials
Child rape case: K’taka CM courts fresh controversy
TV producer found dead under mysterious circumstances in Gzb
AAP won’t contest Haryana assembly polls
Amendments to juvenile justice act to get immediate clearance from govt
BJP reluctant to face polls
It is possible that the BJP believes that like all waves, the Modi wave, too, has started receding. As a result, the party may not be able to replicate last summer’s outcome.
This track doesn’t go anywhere
Congress groupism back with a bang
When jailhouse rock meets eco-justice
Indian bureaucracy: More a caged parrot than the famed steel frame
Modi must plug loopholes
Nation-building needs managers at fore
S S Mantha
Let’s solve this elephantine crisis
‘Request FM to raise allocation for health’
India first in Modi parlance
Rebels hand over MH17 black boxes
Rebels controlling the crash site of Malaysian flight MH17 on Tuesday handed over the plane’s black boxes, and declared a localised truce to allow international experts full access to the forensic minefield in east Ukraine.
MH17 a ‘hideous crime’, probe hurdles an ‘outrage’: IATA
UN, US press Gaza truce efforts as death toll soars
‘I no longer talk to Obama’: Turkish PM
UK govt announces inquiry on Russian spy death
Cambodian political rivals say agreement reached
Britain, UN host first summit to end child marriage
Nigeria president meets kin of schoolgirls held hostage
NATO must beef up eastern flank
Al-Qaida vows to cut off hands of ‘corrupt’ Yemen officials
Trai proposes Rs 2,400-crore plan to connect 2 island UTs
The telecom regulator has recommended that besides connecting ANI and Lakshadweep with cables, satellite connectivity should be retained in parts of both these union territories.
Sensex surges 311 points to recoup 26,000 closing mark
ONGC to accelerate KG basin gas discoveries’ development
Regime change: Modi Govt to be tough with WTO on food security
‘Chinese Apple’ Xiaomi Mi3 makes India entry, stock sold out in 30 mins
India tops Nielsen world consumer confidence list
Sebi bars Ally Multi-Trade from collecting funds from investors
Unveils structure to identify ‘systemically important banks'
RBI relaxes limit on loans against gold ornaments
India cuts Iran’s share in oil import basket
The story of their lives
American center in collaboration with Cinedarbar celebrates the filming, depiction and dramatisation of the life of an important personage from the past and the present era.
Sufi and soul
The flavours of July
From Colombia to the Capital
What women want
Laugh out loud
Three generations bound together
Three forms, one expression
The conscience call
Matter to masterpiece
Only teammates appreciate my efforts
Cynosure of all eyes after his fiery spell earned India its first Test victory at the iconic Lord’s in 28 years, fast bowler Ishant Sharma feels his efforts are never appreciated by people other than his team-mates.
India aim top 3 finish at CWG
Sharma, Bhuvi climb up ICC rankings chart
Tiwary, Pandey script 70-run win for Ind A
Schumi slowly progressing: Wife
There are more happy hookers in the present English team than Soho, says Bob Willis
Hearing on Anderson-Jadeja spat fixed for 1 August
Cook retained as captain for 3rd Test
Real Madrid close to seal Rodriguez deal
Subrata Paul, Nabi to play for Mumbai in ISL
Salman Khan asks: Why so much negativity about Nargis?
The actor defends Fakhri saying that she has done an ‘outstandingly great’ job for the song in Kick and that she and Jacqueline are very simmilar.
For Sonam, Rekha was class apart in Khubsoorat
Christina shrugs off dating rumours with Lil Wayne
Justin Bieber’s freedom in peril?
Zach Braff not interested in dating super-famous girls
Beyonce, Jay Z to split?
Scarlett Johansson likely to marry next month
The Expendables 3 to release as 14 Khiladi in Hindi
Kesha blames media for paranoia
‘Never met grandpa, but proud to be his grandson’
Bet on Black
Football is a continent. No other continent converges like Africa does on a football pitch. FIFA 2014 has brought five African squads to Brazil to chase passion and glory that otherwise stays divided in its 54 countries. But will the cheer last? Cameroon wound up quick and headed home
The five men who did it!
Africans need just one break!
Satao's last stand
Why she loves Kenya!
An African view on African football
Football unites Ghana
Secret treasures of Great Rift Valley
Breathless in Selenkay
Rich Ethiopian Aroma in India
Vandana Singh reports on how our metros, unlike the religious texts, found the south to be more ‘auspicious’
My friend app
This cup is our cup
Change of prism
Left- hearted, right-minded
The Great Indian Art Scam
Chasing a mirage
AAP’s Punjabi tadka!
One seat two many
‘Indians seem to be comfortable with Caucasians writing about themselves’
Perils of decision-making
16 August 2013, New Delhi, Mukesh Kacker
MAILING THE ARTICLE
You have decided to email the following article:
Perils of decision-making
16 August 2013, New Delhi, Mukesh Kacker
* indicates mandatory.
For a bureaucrat, taking a quick decision in good faith is fraught with risks.
The Durga Nagpal controversy has brought to the surface the issue of political interference impeding bureaucratic work. A few months ago, presumably in response to the mounting criticism from prominent Indian industrialists and businessmen about the total lack of decision-making in government, the prime minister exhorted the senior bureaucracy to take decisions fearlessly and expeditiously.
Case in point
X, a brilliant and extremely well-educated senior IAS officer, was posted as the managing director of the state industrial development corporation of a state. He had recently returned to India after acquiring a degree in management from a premier institution overseas as part of mid-career training and was bursting with energy and fresh ideas. The state industrial development corporation was responsible for a wide variety of activities, including development of enabling infrastructure for industries, tying up joint ventures with profitable ventures and giving financial support to industries. In addition, it also acted as the procurer of certain specified industrial products for use by the entire government.
X was delighted with his job because it challenged both his energy and education in management and finance. The chief minister, a wise and forward-looking politician, had hand-picked X for this job and they shared an excellent working relationship. X was also on good terms with most senior bureaucrats, barring the principal secretary (finance), a thoroughly incompetent and malicious officer who owed his position to flattery and licking the boots of the state finance minister, a heavyweight politician with direct links with the high-command of the ruling party at the Centre. The chief secretary, though a decent man otherwise, was a nondescript mediocre who had risen in service primarily because he had been non-controversial. X was not overtly concerned about sharing negative vibes with the principal secretary (finance) as he had limited direct dealings with him. In short, X had as good an environment to operate as can be possible in a real-life situation. The state was experiencing high industrial growth and X, as the central figure, had his hands full. There were bids to be finalised for specific industrial activities and for industrial infrastructure creation.
There were also joint ventures and financing proposals that consumed a lot of his energy and time.
Against this backdrop of intense activities came a subject matter which appeared not just routine but also mundane. As a one-stop procurer of water filters for a large number of government departments and programmes, the corporation had finalised a large tender for water filters just before X had joined. In fact X’s predecessor had approved the supply order in favour of a company that was based in the state just a week before X took over as managing director. At the time of the tender there was some controversy over the state government’s decision to restrict the selection only to those firms that had their manufacturing plants within the state and a few national-level companies had protested and even complained against this decision. The state government, however, had issued a direction to the corporation to select eligible bidders only from companies/firms domiciled in the state. However, all this had taken place before X had joined and he had no role in the entire tender process. X became aware of this case only when the first tranche of supply was ready for dispatch and had to be inspected by the engineers of the corporation at factory site.
The site inspection report brought out a deficiency in the body of the product and X immediately ordered a complete halt to the supply. A notice was also issued to the party, asking them to ‘show cause’ why their order should not be cancelled forthwith. At this point, the corporation received two letters. One was a detailed explanation from the party explaining the cause of the deficiency and promising to remove it and supply the first tranche of the improved product within a month. The second was a representation from the party which was L2 in the tender, asking for cancelling the order given to L1 and awarding it to them (L2) at the tender price. After examining these counter-claims, X found that the defect was a minor one and could be removed within a month as promised. He, therefore, decided that there was no plausible reason for cancelling the supply order and awarding it to L2.
Accordingly, a month’s extension was given to the party to supply the improved product, subject, of course, to another at-site product inspection. After one month, engineers of the corporation inspected the improved product at the site and found it to be compliant with all quality parameters. The supply was resumed and completed, albeit with a month’s delay. During all this, X was completely unaware of the quiet rumblings that would spell trouble for him.
The adverse turn
A national-level manufacturer who was also antagonistic to the state-level party, the supplier in the present case, sent a complaint to the chief minister protesting the decision to restrict eligible bidders to state-level parties and alleging favouritism in awarding the tender to the present supplier. The chief minister, who receives many such complaints every day, marked it to the principal secretary (finance). It was here that an otherwise innocuous piece of paper assumed capabilities of dangerous proportions.
The principal secretary (finance), a malicious and conspiring individual, realised the potential for serious harm to X that this paper held. Within the government, there was nothing to be inquired into, as the government itself had issued an order to the corporation for selecting eligible bidders from state-level parties. But sending it to an independent agency like the lokayukta, which functions independently of the government, could perhaps create trouble for X. So, the PS (finance) quietly forwarded the complaint to the state lokayukta. The case spun out of control from there, as the lokayukta marked the complaint to his police wing which received it with alacrity, always eager to make high-profile bureaucrats bite dust. Could there be anything more ridiculous than section 13(1)(d)(iii)? Can there be any contract where the party winning the bid does not obtain pecuniary gain? And which party’s interpretation of the term ‘public interest’ will be relevant?
On arrangement with Governance Now
For an India of many states
Young and free! Really?
This article has
to post your comment.
POST YOUR COMMENT
You may post as guest, or by
. If logged in, your comment will be posted instantly without moderation by administrator.
* indicates mandatory.
(will not be posted online)
Has the son of India’s richest man killed two persons?
As AICTE loses its case in SC, IIPM crosses 2 million fans on FB
How Ambani’s Reliance corrupted the system
Sex, security and videotapes: CCTV footage from Metro stations find its way to Net
British intelligence alert exposed former CBI chief’s dirty link with meat seller
© Millennium Post. All Rights Reserved.