Logging in will submit your comments on articles instantly without administrator moderation.
* indicates mandatory.
Keep me logged in
AAP govt to form panels to address complaints against Delhi Police
The Delhi Cabinet on Tuesday approved setting up of the State Police Complaint Authority, to be headed by a retired Supreme Court or High Court judge, and the District Level Police Complaint Authority.
Civic bodies to scrap factory licensing dept after failure to meet target
Somnath Bharti seeks bail, says it’s a ‘BJP-sponsored’ case
Sex determination racket busted in Uttam Nagar
Unauthorised colonies: Govt okays development work
Man held with live bullets in Laxmi Ngr Metro station
Even as city grapples with dengue, six new swine flu cases reported
4 women held for smuggling gold worth Rs 3.5 crore
Drunk men fire bullets in air, minor girl injured
NDMC disconnects 230 water, electricity connections
PM Modi changed 16 dresses in US, says Rahul
Says Modi not concerned with problems of farmers, labourers.
Will look beyond India if blockade doesn't end: Nepal
Strongest action against those who disrupt harmony: Rajnath
Additional Spectrum: Court to pass order on charge on Oct 15
2008 blasts case: HC asks special court to conduct speedy trial
FTII row: No breakthrough, talks again on Oct 10
Police triggered violence in Varanasi, alleges BJP
Ghulam Ali's show cancelled following Sena's opposition
Farmers' stir hits train movement in Punjab
Countries must put children first, says Satyarthi
Government goes soft on its banks
Most public sector banks are in a mess, although the Centre continues to be hard on the RBI.
Firoz Bakht Ahmed
Dangers of communal polarisation
India faces tough external environment
Down to Earth
Particle physics and understanding matter
Secure India before you ‘Make in India’
Caught napping by Dengue menace
Down to Earth
Better climate policy for a cleaner India
Voter divided between head & heart
Harmless chemicals or health hazard?
Dengue spreads its wings
Down to Earth
Iraq forces retake areas around Ramadi
A total of 27 strikes have been conducted in the area since last week, according to the US-led coalition’s daily tally of air strikes in Iraq, Syria.
Plea against declaring Dilip’s Pak house as heritage dismissed
‘Russia shouldn’t interfere in US efforts to destroy IS’
Trio wins Nobel Chemistry Prize for DNA repair work
Images of dead Kurdish militant ‘dragged by Turkish police’ spark outrage
Pak SC upholds death sentence of killer of former Punjab Guv
Nepalese ‘donate’ petrol to India in satirical protest
19 killed as Typhoon Mujigae ravages China
Campbell believes Kunduz hospital strike broke US rules : Report
Maldives’ vice-prez denies role in boat ‘assassination bid’
Volkswagen temporarily stops sale of Polo in India
German automaker warns workers of ‘pain’ to come because of scandal. VW India produced 20,030 units of Polo in the April-August period this year. It had sold 13,827 units in the domestic market and 6,052 were exported.
RBI’s e-Kuber be used for account settlement under GST: Panel
Coal imports to be brought to zero in 2-21/2 years: Goyal
ESPN to make comeback on Indian TV, partners MSM for channel
Why hide contracts with FB, YouTube from us: HC asks Centre
Sensex ends above 27k rise 102.95 pts
Rupee hits 8-wk high of 64.95 vs $, rise 46 paise
Delhi HC restrains Glenmark from business of anti-diabetes drugs
BSE to have PAN-based self trade prevention checks in equities
CIS: Sebi clamps down on 25 firms in Apr-Sep FY16
Exploring cultural variety
Old Fort Dance festival will see the participation of veteran artistes such as Pandit Birju Maharaj, Madhvi Mudgal and Leela Samson, who will perform with their groups.
Repeating aloud boosts verbal memory
Self-worth of Indian kids impacted more by father’s role
Gluten intolerance: Dangerous gut-wrenching experience for some
Boss’s bad jokes can improve your job satisfaction
Be positive to keep heart disease at bay
Not just moms, expectant dads get depressed too
Manganiyar musician launches debut album
Verbal praise for complex task could backfire
Shashank Manohar’s reforms: Constitution uploaded, auditor changed
In line with president Shashank Manohar’s declaration of the reforms that will be carried out, the BCCI on Wednesday uploaded its ‘Constitution’ on the official website and also removed the Chennai-based tax auditor firm.
India to play for pride in dead rubber
India beat New Zealand 3-1 to square hockey series
Lahiri’s humour adds to his skills and wins him more friends
Lahiri-Thonchai a ‘perfect pair’ for President Cup
Blatter slams ‘outrageous’ condemnation
10-man Atletico de Kolkata hold FC Goa to a 1-1 draw
Hotel bills not paid, special athletes’ passports confiscated
Arjuna awardee boxer suspended on bribery charge
Will play as long as I enjoy the game: Yuvi
‘No film can flop if planned properly: Aishwarya
The actor, who will be seen essaying the role of an advocate says that a film can be successful only when it is planned properly.
Irrfan, Kangana to work together in film on Begum Akhtar?
Was sexually harassed by Hollywood film executive: Ashley Judd
Jennifer, Jack Huston join The Yellow Birds
Rita & Travis’s date night at Universal Studios
Bieber slams One Direction for same day release
Tom Hanks would officiate more weddings if the fee is right
Cyrus breaks down in tears during SNL performance
Padma Shri for Kader Khan?
‘Rahman has created magic with ‘Tamasha’ songs’
Is India still sleeping?
The 3rd India-Africa Summit is an opportunity for New Delhi not to be caught following the dragon’s tail but rather setting its own mark in its African engagement, writes Sanusha Naidu.
Eye of the camera
Queen of the wild nurtures Indian wilderness
Of love and loss
My first day in India
Shiva, Devendro enter quarters; Mandeep bows out
Wake up call for india
Intertwining Indo-African dreams
India’s Africa policy under Modi
Is there a future for Kenya’s lions?
In a chain reaction to the rapid growth being witnessed in Noida, Greater Noida and adjoining Yamuna Expressway farmers and land-owners, who got a good compensation for their land after selling it to private builders, are now purchasing more land in other parts of Westen UP. This has led to a boom in the agricultural land prices.
Right to live
To caste or to castaway
Cheap phones, big dreams
Inked in blood
Phishing for trouble
Revival or recantation
Perils of decision-making
16 August 2013, New Delhi, Mukesh Kacker
MAILING THE ARTICLE
You have decided to email the following article:
Perils of decision-making
16 August 2013, New Delhi, Mukesh Kacker
* indicates mandatory.
For a bureaucrat, taking a quick decision in good faith is fraught with risks.
The Durga Nagpal controversy has brought to the surface the issue of political interference impeding bureaucratic work. A few months ago, presumably in response to the mounting criticism from prominent Indian industrialists and businessmen about the total lack of decision-making in government, the prime minister exhorted the senior bureaucracy to take decisions fearlessly and expeditiously.
Case in point
X, a brilliant and extremely well-educated senior IAS officer, was posted as the managing director of the state industrial development corporation of a state. He had recently returned to India after acquiring a degree in management from a premier institution overseas as part of mid-career training and was bursting with energy and fresh ideas. The state industrial development corporation was responsible for a wide variety of activities, including development of enabling infrastructure for industries, tying up joint ventures with profitable ventures and giving financial support to industries. In addition, it also acted as the procurer of certain specified industrial products for use by the entire government.
X was delighted with his job because it challenged both his energy and education in management and finance. The chief minister, a wise and forward-looking politician, had hand-picked X for this job and they shared an excellent working relationship. X was also on good terms with most senior bureaucrats, barring the principal secretary (finance), a thoroughly incompetent and malicious officer who owed his position to flattery and licking the boots of the state finance minister, a heavyweight politician with direct links with the high-command of the ruling party at the Centre. The chief secretary, though a decent man otherwise, was a nondescript mediocre who had risen in service primarily because he had been non-controversial. X was not overtly concerned about sharing negative vibes with the principal secretary (finance) as he had limited direct dealings with him. In short, X had as good an environment to operate as can be possible in a real-life situation. The state was experiencing high industrial growth and X, as the central figure, had his hands full. There were bids to be finalised for specific industrial activities and for industrial infrastructure creation.
There were also joint ventures and financing proposals that consumed a lot of his energy and time.
Against this backdrop of intense activities came a subject matter which appeared not just routine but also mundane. As a one-stop procurer of water filters for a large number of government departments and programmes, the corporation had finalised a large tender for water filters just before X had joined. In fact X’s predecessor had approved the supply order in favour of a company that was based in the state just a week before X took over as managing director. At the time of the tender there was some controversy over the state government’s decision to restrict the selection only to those firms that had their manufacturing plants within the state and a few national-level companies had protested and even complained against this decision. The state government, however, had issued a direction to the corporation to select eligible bidders only from companies/firms domiciled in the state. However, all this had taken place before X had joined and he had no role in the entire tender process. X became aware of this case only when the first tranche of supply was ready for dispatch and had to be inspected by the engineers of the corporation at factory site.
The site inspection report brought out a deficiency in the body of the product and X immediately ordered a complete halt to the supply. A notice was also issued to the party, asking them to ‘show cause’ why their order should not be cancelled forthwith. At this point, the corporation received two letters. One was a detailed explanation from the party explaining the cause of the deficiency and promising to remove it and supply the first tranche of the improved product within a month. The second was a representation from the party which was L2 in the tender, asking for cancelling the order given to L1 and awarding it to them (L2) at the tender price. After examining these counter-claims, X found that the defect was a minor one and could be removed within a month as promised. He, therefore, decided that there was no plausible reason for cancelling the supply order and awarding it to L2.
Accordingly, a month’s extension was given to the party to supply the improved product, subject, of course, to another at-site product inspection. After one month, engineers of the corporation inspected the improved product at the site and found it to be compliant with all quality parameters. The supply was resumed and completed, albeit with a month’s delay. During all this, X was completely unaware of the quiet rumblings that would spell trouble for him.
The adverse turn
A national-level manufacturer who was also antagonistic to the state-level party, the supplier in the present case, sent a complaint to the chief minister protesting the decision to restrict eligible bidders to state-level parties and alleging favouritism in awarding the tender to the present supplier. The chief minister, who receives many such complaints every day, marked it to the principal secretary (finance). It was here that an otherwise innocuous piece of paper assumed capabilities of dangerous proportions.
The principal secretary (finance), a malicious and conspiring individual, realised the potential for serious harm to X that this paper held. Within the government, there was nothing to be inquired into, as the government itself had issued an order to the corporation for selecting eligible bidders from state-level parties. But sending it to an independent agency like the lokayukta, which functions independently of the government, could perhaps create trouble for X. So, the PS (finance) quietly forwarded the complaint to the state lokayukta. The case spun out of control from there, as the lokayukta marked the complaint to his police wing which received it with alacrity, always eager to make high-profile bureaucrats bite dust. Could there be anything more ridiculous than section 13(1)(d)(iii)? Can there be any contract where the party winning the bid does not obtain pecuniary gain? And which party’s interpretation of the term ‘public interest’ will be relevant?
On arrangement with Governance Now
For an India of many states
Young and free! Really?
This article has
to post your comment.
POST YOUR COMMENT
You may post as guest, or by
. If logged in, your comment will be posted instantly without moderation by administrator.
* indicates mandatory.
(will not be posted online)
Has the son of India’s richest man killed two persons?
As AICTE loses its case in SC, IIPM crosses 2 million fans on FB
How Ambani’s Reliance corrupted the system
British intelligence alert exposed former CBI chief’s dirty link with meat seller
Sex, security and videotapes: CCTV footage from Metro stations find its way to Net
© Millennium Post. All Rights Reserved.