Logging in will submit your comments on articles instantly without administrator moderation.
* indicates mandatory.
Keep me logged in
Doctors divided over debate on chikungunya deaths in Delhi
Amid debate over chikungunya deaths in the city, opinion of doctors seem to be divided with some asserting only 0.1 per cent people run the risk of dying due to its complications.
Army jawan arrested for molesting neighbour’s girl
Unborn foetus found in Rao Tula Ram hospital’s toilet
Man who blackmailed minors by sending morphed pics arrested
Cops arrest ex-employee of elderly man for killing him
Race Course Metro station to be renamed Lok Kalyan Marg stn
Delhi Police rejig DCPs and Additional DCPs
Mishra dares ACB to arrest Dikshit
Girl’s throat slit for saying no to marriage, youth held
Cop’s son shot dead over monetary dispute
Fresh plea in SC against grant of bail to Shahabuddin
In fresh trouble for RJD leader Mohd Shahabuddin, the mother of three youths who were brutally killed by henchmen of the controversial politician has moved the Supreme Court seeking cancellation of bail granted to him.
Youth carries father’s body in hand cart; video goes viral
Nitish is Bihar CM due to Lalu: Amar
Mahanadi: Odisha rejects Centre’s plea to form panel
ISRO begins countdown for big launch
Cong raises questions, asks BJP to publish final details of contract
Udai Pratap is DDA Vice-Chairman
Sharif ignites Indo-Pak tension, Modi says India will not forget Uri
5 dead in shooting at mall in Washington
India will not forget Uri: PM Modi
Economy still stuck around 7-7.5 %
Desperate moves on budget and privatisation.
Hardeep S Puri
Sharif's UN speech a monumental error of judgement
Down to Earth
Make polluters pay the price
Changing perceptions and the environment
Who cares for the lost children?
Chandra Bhushan Sharma
Another futile toilet chase?
When the Indian media wants bloodshed
The great Arunachal flip-flop
Next-Gen security can minimise cyber-atacks
India’s great farm pond chase
Shooting in Baltimore leaves several injured as police search for 3 gunmen
Three gunmen shot and wounded eight people, including a 3-year-old girl, on an east Baltimore street on Saturday night, police said, adding that the suspects fled and the victims were all expected to survive.
Firing, suicide bombing kill 12 in Iraq’s Tikrit
UN Security Council backs nuke test ban implementation
Tamils stage protest to highlight issues in SL
Jeremy Corbyn re-elected as Labour leader in UK
Washington mall shooting suspect arrested, identified
Tulsa officer opened fire in ‘heat of passion’
Eight firefighters charred in Moscow inferno
New poll shows people trust Clinton more
UK suffers first ministerial resignation under May
Parliamentary panel to examine merger of budgets
With the Cabinet's approving the merger of Railway Budget with General Budget, the parliamentary panel on finance has decided to 'examine' the move along with its "ramifications thereof".
‘GM mustard would be disastrous for India’s agricultural independence’
Maruti has ‘M S Dhoni inspired’ Alto special edition
SC rejects PIL against recruiting private bank heads as PSB chiefs
Two Malaysians face arrest warrants in Aircel-Maxis case
Aircel-Maxis case: Arrest warrants against 2 Malaysian men
August M&A deals rise three-fold to $2.5 billion
Engineers India Ltd shines, earns Rs 1,496 cr income in 2015-16
Govt cuts import duty on wheat, potato, palm oils
Focus on R&D, innovation to tap steel market: Birender Singh
‘Likes’ on Facebook may not affect purposeful people
While it is nice to receive compliments, online or otherwise, it may not be a good thing to base one’s self-esteem on them.
Beliefs can worsen pain, insomnia conditions
Smoking impact on DNA even 30 years after quitting
Indulge in ‘king of cheeses’ this weekend
C-section delivery may produce blood clots
History of Indo-Persian literature
VR training improves social skills of autistic individuals
Classical Dance The backbone of Indian Culture
Parent-child bonds may affect your mid-life health
Rejuvenating aesthetics of flute
Unhappy Ronaldo subbed as Madrid held by Las Palmas
A substituted Cristiano Ronaldo cut a disconsolate figure as Real Madrid conceded a late equaliser to draw 2-2 at Las Palmas.
United maul defending champions Leicester
Pakistan cricket community ridicules Thakur’s controversial statement
Sania Mirza-Barbora Strycova win Toray Pan Pacific Open
Eden gears up for tryst with India’s 250th Test at home
Ashwin, Jadeja spin out Kiwis
Pakistan cricket community ridicules Thakur's statement
Ashwin, Jadeja weave spin web around Kiwis
Rooney's place not sacrosanct, says Mourinho
Srikanth loses, Indian challenge over in Japan Super Series
PINK: Challenging the accepted
If women stand by each other, they will be invincible. The moment they don't, men would take advantage of them, says producer Shoojit Sircar.
Kajol makes her debut on Facebook
Zindagi channel might ban all Pakistani TV shows
Chris Pratt scolds fan who curses him
Don't think it will be difficult to gel with Farhan: Kriti
Education is the way out of tunnel: Nimrat
Chris Brown faces investigation from child services
Brad Pitt hires Charlie Sheen’s divorce lawyer
A R Rahman gave me an identity in music industry: Neeti Mohan
Haven’t opted out of ‘Manmarziyan’
Draped in colours
Behind the glitz and glamour of the recently held third India Africa forum summit lies a simple fact that India is still as clueless about its intentions and policy towards Africa as it has always been, reports Kriti Upadhyaya.
African voices in India
Inspiring Kenyan warriors to save lions
Queen of the wild nurtures Indian wilderness
Indian eves lose to NZ in four-nation series opener
Africa talks to Africa Rising - Unprecedented and historic
Africa talks to Africa Rising - Of trade and technology
Africa talks to Africa Rising - Of India
Zambia @51 Message from Acting High Commissioner Sikapale Henry Chinzewe
Uniting india and africa with music
Once bitten,better be twice shy
Chikungunya outbreak is not limited to just Delhi but several states including Bengal in the east and Maharashtra in the west are in the grip of the deadly disease. Anup Verma bemoans that despite knowing the culprit and reason, vector-borne diseases keep casting shadow on nation's health
A city of faith
Pregnant with questions
Mother Teresa - Saint of a woman
Once there was a Garden City
Pangs of Partition
Tech & Tales
Perils of decision-making
16 August 2013, New Delhi, Mukesh Kacker
MAILING THE ARTICLE
You have decided to email the following article:
Perils of decision-making
16 August 2013, New Delhi, Mukesh Kacker
* indicates mandatory.
For a bureaucrat, taking a quick decision in good faith is fraught with risks.
The Durga Nagpal controversy has brought to the surface the issue of political interference impeding bureaucratic work. A few months ago, presumably in response to the mounting criticism from prominent Indian industrialists and businessmen about the total lack of decision-making in government, the prime minister exhorted the senior bureaucracy to take decisions fearlessly and expeditiously.
Case in point
X, a brilliant and extremely well-educated senior IAS officer, was posted as the managing director of the state industrial development corporation of a state. He had recently returned to India after acquiring a degree in management from a premier institution overseas as part of mid-career training and was bursting with energy and fresh ideas. The state industrial development corporation was responsible for a wide variety of activities, including development of enabling infrastructure for industries, tying up joint ventures with profitable ventures and giving financial support to industries. In addition, it also acted as the procurer of certain specified industrial products for use by the entire government.
X was delighted with his job because it challenged both his energy and education in management and finance. The chief minister, a wise and forward-looking politician, had hand-picked X for this job and they shared an excellent working relationship. X was also on good terms with most senior bureaucrats, barring the principal secretary (finance), a thoroughly incompetent and malicious officer who owed his position to flattery and licking the boots of the state finance minister, a heavyweight politician with direct links with the high-command of the ruling party at the Centre. The chief secretary, though a decent man otherwise, was a nondescript mediocre who had risen in service primarily because he had been non-controversial. X was not overtly concerned about sharing negative vibes with the principal secretary (finance) as he had limited direct dealings with him. In short, X had as good an environment to operate as can be possible in a real-life situation. The state was experiencing high industrial growth and X, as the central figure, had his hands full. There were bids to be finalised for specific industrial activities and for industrial infrastructure creation.
There were also joint ventures and financing proposals that consumed a lot of his energy and time.
Against this backdrop of intense activities came a subject matter which appeared not just routine but also mundane. As a one-stop procurer of water filters for a large number of government departments and programmes, the corporation had finalised a large tender for water filters just before X had joined. In fact X’s predecessor had approved the supply order in favour of a company that was based in the state just a week before X took over as managing director. At the time of the tender there was some controversy over the state government’s decision to restrict the selection only to those firms that had their manufacturing plants within the state and a few national-level companies had protested and even complained against this decision. The state government, however, had issued a direction to the corporation to select eligible bidders only from companies/firms domiciled in the state. However, all this had taken place before X had joined and he had no role in the entire tender process. X became aware of this case only when the first tranche of supply was ready for dispatch and had to be inspected by the engineers of the corporation at factory site.
The site inspection report brought out a deficiency in the body of the product and X immediately ordered a complete halt to the supply. A notice was also issued to the party, asking them to ‘show cause’ why their order should not be cancelled forthwith. At this point, the corporation received two letters. One was a detailed explanation from the party explaining the cause of the deficiency and promising to remove it and supply the first tranche of the improved product within a month. The second was a representation from the party which was L2 in the tender, asking for cancelling the order given to L1 and awarding it to them (L2) at the tender price. After examining these counter-claims, X found that the defect was a minor one and could be removed within a month as promised. He, therefore, decided that there was no plausible reason for cancelling the supply order and awarding it to L2.
Accordingly, a month’s extension was given to the party to supply the improved product, subject, of course, to another at-site product inspection. After one month, engineers of the corporation inspected the improved product at the site and found it to be compliant with all quality parameters. The supply was resumed and completed, albeit with a month’s delay. During all this, X was completely unaware of the quiet rumblings that would spell trouble for him.
The adverse turn
A national-level manufacturer who was also antagonistic to the state-level party, the supplier in the present case, sent a complaint to the chief minister protesting the decision to restrict eligible bidders to state-level parties and alleging favouritism in awarding the tender to the present supplier. The chief minister, who receives many such complaints every day, marked it to the principal secretary (finance). It was here that an otherwise innocuous piece of paper assumed capabilities of dangerous proportions.
The principal secretary (finance), a malicious and conspiring individual, realised the potential for serious harm to X that this paper held. Within the government, there was nothing to be inquired into, as the government itself had issued an order to the corporation for selecting eligible bidders from state-level parties. But sending it to an independent agency like the lokayukta, which functions independently of the government, could perhaps create trouble for X. So, the PS (finance) quietly forwarded the complaint to the state lokayukta. The case spun out of control from there, as the lokayukta marked the complaint to his police wing which received it with alacrity, always eager to make high-profile bureaucrats bite dust. Could there be anything more ridiculous than section 13(1)(d)(iii)? Can there be any contract where the party winning the bid does not obtain pecuniary gain? And which party’s interpretation of the term ‘public interest’ will be relevant?
On arrangement with Governance Now
For an India of many states
Young and free! Really?
This article has
to post your comment.
POST YOUR COMMENT
You may post as guest, or by
. If logged in, your comment will be posted instantly without moderation by administrator.
* indicates mandatory.
(will not be posted online)
Has the son of India’s richest man killed two persons?
IAF planning to induct women in fighter aircraft stream: Air Force chief
Why is Aveek Sarkar so desperate to discredit Mamata Banerjee?
As AICTE loses its case in SC, IIPM crosses 2 million fans on FB
LG cancels Sisodia’s trip but has no time to meet AAP ministers
© Millennium Post. All Rights Reserved.